Definition:
The consistency principle is the accounting principle that requires an entity to apply the same accounting methods, policies, and standards for preparing and reporting its financial statements.
The main objective of the consistency principle is to avoid any intention from management to use an inconsistent approach to manipulate the financial information to ensure their financial statements look healthy.
And sometimes, management could use the inconstancy principle on the same accounting transactions or accounting even in their financial records. It is a huge risk to the user of financial statements if they are not fairly present.
IFRS also requires the entity to apply the same accounting policies in reporting its financial statements. In case there is any change in accounting policies and estimates, IAS 8 should be used.
In addition, this concept, the consistency principle, is also quite important for users of financial statements, investors, and shareholders.
As long as the financial statements consistently use accounting policies and principles, the financial statements will be more accurate and reliable.
The correctness of decision-making highly depends on the accuracy of financial information.
Why is the accounting principle inconsistent?
There are many cases that caused the entity to apply inconsistent accounting principles or policies. For example, there is a requirement to change accounting policies by the standard setter.
There is a requirement from the regulator of those jurisdictions and also a requirement from the entity itself.
All of these things cause the entity to apply the inconsistency principle. And the solution is the find the guideline on how to deal with it.
Different accounting standards probably use different guidelines. For example, if the financial statements use IFRS. The Consistency Principle that you should follow is IAS 8.
What is the Purpose of the Consistency Principle?
The consistency principle is a fundamental accounting principle that requires entities to use the same accounting methods and principles for similar transactions and events over time.
The purpose of this principle is to ensure that financial statements are comparable from one period to the next and that changes in an entity’s financial position and performance can be accurately assessed over time.
Consistency in accounting methods and principles is critical for the users of financial statements because it enables them to make meaningful comparisons between financial statements from different periods.
When entities use consistent accounting methods and principles, users can more easily identify trends, changes, and anomalies in an entity’s financial position and performance.
The consistency principle is particularly important when it comes to the application of accounting standards. Entities must ensure that they apply accounting standards consistently and in a manner that accurately reflects the economic substance of transactions and events.
Inconsistencies in the application of accounting standards can lead to distortions in financial statements and make it difficult for users to accurately assess an entity’s financial position and performance.
Another benefit of the consistency principle is that it promotes accuracy and reliability in financial reporting. When entities use consistent accounting methods and principles, they can more easily identify errors and omissions in financial statements, allowing them to correct any inaccuracies before the financial statements are released to users.
Overall, the purpose of the consistency principle is to ensure that financial statements are comparable from one period to the next and that changes in an entity’s financial position and performance can be accurately assessed over time.
By promoting consistency in accounting methods and principles, the consistency principle helps to ensure the accuracy, reliability, and usefulness of financial reporting for all users.
What is the Limitation of the Consistency Principle?
While the consistency principle is a fundamental accounting principle that ensures the comparability of financial statements over time, there are several limitations to its effectiveness.
These limitations include:
- Changes in accounting standards: The consistency principle requires entities to use the same accounting methods and principles over time, but changes in accounting standards may make it necessary for entities to change their accounting methods. When accounting standards change, entities may need to make adjustments to their financial statements to ensure compliance, potentially compromising the consistency of their financial statements.
- Changes in business operations: Entities may change their business operations over time, which can affect the relevance of past accounting methods and principles. When entities change their business operations, they may need to adjust their accounting methods and principles, potentially compromising the consistency of their financial statements.
- Limited comparability: While the consistency principle promotes comparability between financial statements from different periods, it may not be possible to achieve complete comparability due to differences in the nature and scope of transactions and events over time. In some cases, entities may need to use different accounting methods or principles to accurately reflect the economic substance of transactions and events, limiting the comparability of financial statements over time.
- Lack of transparency: The consistency principle may not always be transparent to users of financial statements. Entities may use different accounting methods or principles for similar transactions and events, but these differences may not be readily apparent to users of financial statements. This lack of transparency can compromise the usefulness of financial statements for users.
- Potential for manipulation: The consistency principle may be subject to manipulation by entities seeking to present a particular financial picture. Entities may selectively change their accounting methods or principles to manipulate their financial statements, potentially compromising the consistency and comparability of their financial statements.
Why is the Consistency Principle Important in Accounting?
The consistency principle is important in accounting because it ensures that financial statements are comparable from one period to another.
This principle requires entities to use the same accounting methods and principles for similar transactions and events over time, promoting consistency and accuracy in financial reporting.
The purpose of financial statements is to provide information about an entity’s financial position and performance to its users, such as investors, creditors, and regulators.
When financial statements are consistent over time, users can more easily identify trends, changes, and anomalies in an entity’s financial position and performance.
Consistency also allows users to make meaningful comparisons between financial statements from different periods, helping them to better understand an entity’s financial performance and make informed decisions.
In addition to promoting comparability and accuracy in financial reporting, the consistency principle also promotes transparency in accounting.
Entities that use consistent accounting methods and principles are more likely to provide clear and reliable information to users, promoting trust and confidence in financial reporting.
Moreover, the consistency principle helps entities to identify errors and omissions in financial statements, enabling them to correct any inaccuracies before the financial statements are released to users.
This can prevent users from making decisions based on inaccurate or misleading financial information.
Overall, the consistency principle is important in accounting because it promotes accuracy, comparability, transparency, and reliability in financial reporting.
By requiring entities to use consistent accounting methods and principles over time, the consistency principle helps to ensure that financial statements are useful and relevant to all users.
Example of the consistency principle:
For example,
Company A’s Financial Statements report base on IFRS. Its accounting policies for depreciation are using a straight-line basis. In 2014 and 2015, it uses a straight line.
But, the company subsequently wants to change its accounting policies from a straight line to a declining balance.
In this case, the entity should apply with IAS 8 whether it is a retrospective or prospective change. All of the change requires full disclosure in the financial statements and how the change is affected. This is how we apply the Consistency Principle.
Sometimes, management’s performance is based on Net Sales or Net Profit, and the way how management not complying the Consistency Principle in their Financial Statements is also based on this.
For example, if the performance is based on Net Sales, management might not recognize revenues by using the same accounting policies.
And if management performance is based on Net Profit, management might play around with operating expenses to ensure that net profit looks favorable. For example, through depreciation, accrual, and other expenses.
If you have any comments related to the Consistency Principle, please drop them here or create a new topic in our forum.
Written by Sinra